About Us
Love at First Bite
Our Story
Here you'll find authentic Italian pizza that you can't find anywhere else. Except maybe Italy.
With every meal prepared to order, using freshly, in house made dough and sauce, the experience is love at first bite ❤️.
With three locations in Buford, Lawrenceville, and Winder, plus our famous food truck for catering and events, we're bringing authentic Italian flavors to the Atlanta metro area.
Owner Rafaelo personally ensures every customer feels like family. His passion for pizza and dedication to quality is what makes Italian Pizza Pie special.
3
Locations
What Makes Us Special
Fresh Daily
Our dough and sauce are made fresh every single day. No shortcuts, no compromises.
Authentic Recipes
Traditional Italian recipes passed down through generations, made with love.
Made to Order
Every meal is prepared fresh when you order. That's the Italian Pizza Pie promise.
What Our Customers Say
"Winder has been needing a good local pizza spot!!! It's nice to see the community supporting local business because this place is busy but the seating is very friendly for larger parties. It is family friendly and the atmosphere really feels that way. The service was good and of course the pizza was amazing. I've been to the other locations and I'm really happy to see it maintains its authenticity."
Andres V.
Atlanta, GA • Yelp • December 2025
"Amazing experience at Italian Pie in downtown Winder. The owner, Rafaelo, personally took care of us, which made it even more special. The Hawaiian pizza was perfectly baked with fresh ingredients and great flavor balance. Highly recommended—true passion for pizza here!"
CH Pulgarin
Local Guide • Google • January 2026
"Ordered take out and picked it up. The order process was easy with a live person. Order was ready when I arrived to pick up. The food was amazing and the portions were huge! Service and staff were very nice."
Marcia S.
Bethlehem, GA • Yelp • January 2026
"DELICIOUS pizza! So super happy we finally have a good pizza near us. Their subs are just as good! Everything taste homemade if not close to it. I just wish they had a bit better fries but there's plenty more appetizers to choose from. They have great prices for the size as well!"
Hunter Lynn
Local Guide • Google • January 2026
"This is such a great, casual restaurant. The pizza and antipasto salad were amazing! The pizza crust is light and crispy. What a wonderful addition to downtown Winder."
Tracey Bell
Local Guide • Google • January 2026
"WELL........DONE!!!!!! I applaud you Italian Pizza Pie!! Extremely well done on this Philly. Perfect amount of crust on both bread and meat. Cheese was melted just right. And the flavor was above and beyond the call of duty! Picture does this delicious sandwich no justice."
Philly Lover
Winder, GA • Yelp • January 2026
Come Experience the Difference
Visit any of our three locations or book our food truck for your next event!